By Ben Tindall, Executive Director, Save Family Farming

The Save Family Farming team has spent over a year watching the WA State Department of Health (DOH) turn a fairly simple violation complaint into a spectacular, jaw-dropping example of bureaucratic foot-dragging, contradictory messages, astonishing cowardice, and what appears to be an endless appetite for excuses and inaction. I’m absolutely beyond fed up!

For more than a year, Save Family Farming has been trying to get some resolution after an anti-farming activist group, Empowering Latina Leadership and Action (ELLA), misused the DOH’s official logo on videos attacking agriculture and promoting its own lobbying efforts. The same organization received $499,200 in taxpayer funds through the DOH, which helped fund its media production and led to an anti-farming propaganda piece.

The DOH admitted the logos were unauthorized and acknowledged it funded the video’s production, while also claiming it did not endorse the content. The DOH asked ELLA to remove the logos, and ELLA assured them the problem was fixed. But we quickly discovered that promise was an absolute, total, and blatant lie!

Instead of checking for themselves, DOH decided just to take the organization’s word. When I brought up the documented evidence showing the videos were unchanged, the department finally admitted its failure. I met with DOH Assistant Secretary Lauren Jenks, who said they would keep communicating with ELLA and ask it to either pull the videos or edit out the logos. Yet, about a month later, Jenks came back and said DOH decided a conveniently buried disclaimer on ELLA’s social media was good enough, while leaving the unauthorized logos untouched and proudly on display in the original videos.

In that final meeting, Jenks was absolutely clear: “We are not coming at them with accountability.” Wait, what? Let that sink in.

A senior official at a Washington state agency, responsible for administering public resources and enforcing the conditions attached to them, told me accountability wasn’t an objective. Then, what exactly is the objective? Protecting taxpayers? Upholding standards that the state set for itself? Are they not even interested in protecting the state’s own credibility? It appears that it was simply more important to make an inconvenient complaint disappear.

In my view, Washington farmers ought to be absolutely incensed!

Every farmer who’s had to put up with inspections, the regulatory regime, compliance deadlines, paperwork, and the threat of penalties should ask why an activist NGO is apparently entitled to such a low standard of accountability in comparison.

Imagine a farmer going to a state regulator and saying that a violation had been cured when it hadn’t. Imagine missing the next deadline, offering an excuse that no one ever bothered to check, and then expecting the regulator to walk away and say it’s all sorted out.

It would be utterly ridiculous, as it should be!

Yet somehow that’s exactly the kind of extraordinary leniency ELLA received, and it makes the whole concept of government oversight a complete and utter joke.

I want to be clear. ELLA is entitled to its views, however distorted, however selective, and however hostile to agriculture I think they are. Yes, it can produce propaganda films, malign farmers, and pursue its own political agenda.

That said, it has no right to borrow the credibility of the Washington State Department of Health and use it to make those misleading messages look government-endorsed. It also surely shouldn’t be able to expect taxpayer funding without some enforceable obligations (dare I say accountability).

The most infuriating thing is that we at Save Family Farming did absolutely everything the government asks concerned citizens to do. We documented the issue. We made complaints. We provided evidence. We followed up. We met with agency leadership. We gave the DOH every opportunity to show some spine and demonstrate they would do something about it. They confirmed that ELLA was wrong, had breached the rules, and would take corrective action. Yet the outcome was a complete and utter year-long bureaucratic merry-go-round of contradictions, broken promises, excuses, and a total lack of follow-through.

What a rotten message to send Washington farmers, who already have the distinct impression that the state government cares far more about regulating them than protecting their ability to produce food.

And what an encouraging message to the next activist organization that’s going to get taxpayer money: carry on and disregard rules, ignore the deadlines, give assurances that are absolutely not true, and perhaps the state will eventually conclude that accountability is just too much of an inconvenience. That is the dangerous precedent that the DOH has established in this case.

So now we’re wondering, where’s the outrage from Olympia? Who is the leader that’s going to demand answers from these agencies that are using taxpayer dollars to produce this deceptive anti-farming propaganda and putting the state’s seal of approval on it? The WA State Legislature and State Auditor should independently look into this case, but also more importantly, the larger issue of oversight of Climate Commitment Act grants. They should demand the documentation, investigate the non-compliance, and ask why, after the agency acknowledged a violation, it took a year to get so little.

Washington taxpayers deserve better.

Farmers must also face an uncomfortable reality: they can’t rely on state agencies to protect agriculture from misleading attacks, even when the state’s own resources and identity are at stake. From all of this, I’ve seen that we have to be louder and more persistent. If farmers want a fair shake, we have to be absolutely determined that truth will not be swallowed up by well-funded activist messaging or bureaucratic apathy.

This whole mess should never have taken anywhere close to a year. That it did, and that it ended with so little accountability, should embarrass everyone involved. I’m sick of the excuses. I’m sick of the double standards. I’m sick of farmers being expected to play by the book while others seem to get a free hand to ignore it.

Accountability isn’t accountability if it’s optional. We depend on government oversight, but it exists only if someone has the guts to enforce it. Enough is enough. Washington needs action, not another year of bureaucratic excuses.